THE PARANORMAL PASTOR’S Number 1 Paranormal film: Lake Mungo (2008)

JD digs into Lake Mungo and explains how it gives us subtle supernatural phenomena, skepticism, and psychological realism.

A big “thank you” to everyone who has been keeping up with this series so far. Alas, we crown our champion: 2008’s Lake Mungo. Written and directed by Joel Anderson (Late Night With The Devil), this documentary style true-crime film sits above the rest in its authenticity. The plot follows a family experiencing supernatural events after the drowning and rediscovering of the body of their sixteen-year-old daughter, Alice Palmer. The family then seeks the help of psychic and parapsychologist, Ray Kemeny. And things get interesting.

One of the reasons this film works so well is that like Noroi, it’s done in a documentary style, making you feel as if you are watching Unsolved Mysteries or another docuseries. We get sit down interviews with the family, news style footage, and police reports. There’s also psychics being interviewed like on real TV specials and photographic evidence being analyzed. Because of this structure the film feels like a real case file.

Another thing I love about it is the supernatural/paranormal evidence is subtle. Like other films on my list, there are no jump-scare ghosts floating around corners or popping out of tight spaces. There are no dramatic CGI manifestations and no violent, powerful ghosts that require you to suspend logic. What we get instead are blurry photos, grainy videos, and things that could be misinterpretations of the data. This mirrors real investigations where things are indistinct, ambiguous, and often discovered later.

Next, I want to talk about the acting. The family behaves like real, grieving people. The style is restrained in the sense that there is no dramatic screaming or reactions to things. The fear is also subtle and never exaggerated. The family shows lots of quiet confusion. There are times where the grief is delayed, and the interviews come across as awkward and uncomfortable, showing uncertainty about what they think happened. All of their actions mimic authentic bereavement psychology, thus adding more layers of realism to the movie.

My favorite aspect of realism in the film, however, is how the paranormal is treated with scepticism. Some of the other movies I’ve mentioned add hints of this, but none to the extent and execution as Lake Mungo. We actively see alternative explanations being explored in a serious manner. We even have some of the evidence being debunked along the way. This is how real-life investigative methodology works. Claims appear and evidence is reviewed. Some of the explanations are disproven, and oftentimes you are left with ambiguity.

There are two final layers I want to bring to your attention (mild spoilers ahead). First is the FOCUS of the horror. Even though this is a paranormal film, the horror is existential and not supernatural. The real terror isn’t the ghost. It’s the IDEA that the girl knew her fate before she died. The movie explores themes like premonition, grief, the hidden lives of loved ones, as well as the unknowability of other people. What happens to the viewer is the psychological realism comes across as so authentic, it makes the paranormal feel philosophically plausible rather than theoretical.

Finally, the end reveal recontextualizes the entire film. The last photographs reveal the ghost may have been present the entire time, hidden in the background of earlier footage. In real life investigations, anomalies in older photos are often discovered later. This slow revelation gives Lake Mungo another piece of realism that causes it to stand above all the rest.

Are there any weaknesses in the film? Yes, but they are minute. It could be argued that the psychic element feels a little too convenient. The scene with the phone footage discovery also seems a little bit too dramatically perfect. Other than this, the film is near perfect.

Final score: 4.9/5.

Known by his fans as “The Paranormal Pastor,” JD Hill brings a unique and original touch to the dark fiction genre. His twenty plus years in ministry have afforded him the opportunity to encounter people from all walks of life and in a myriad of situations. These experiences have leaked into his stories in numerous ways. He is from Baton Rouge, Louisiana and has four children.

PLEASE NOTE: The views and opinions of the staff of Memento Mori Ink do not necessarily represent those of Memento Mori Ink or Crystal Lake Publishing. Thank you for understanding.