SAVANNAH VS. EDEN UNDONE: The True Story of Sex, Murder, and Utopia at the Dawn of WWII

We continue our deep dive into the “Eden Affair” as Savannah reads the book, comprised of diaries, letters, newspaper clippings, and memoirs.

EDEN UNDONE: The True Story of Sex, Murder, and Utopia at the Dawn of WWII

By Abbot Kahler

352 pp

Published by CROWN

Eden Undone: The True Story of Sex, Murder, and Utopia at the Dawn of WWII is a masterfully woven work of non-fiction from Abbot Kahler. Pieced together with bits of diaries, letters, newspaper clippings, and even memoirs, Kahler delivers a meticulously researched account of what happened on the mysterious island of Floreana.

First, there’s the toxic relationship between Friedrich Ritter and Dore Strauch. Meeting in Germany first as a doctor and patient, the two began a tumultuous relationship, both while married to other people. Friedrich fancied himself a philosopher, and believed he alone could create utopia by mastering himself and the elements, Dore stroked his ego along the way, believing she could help him reach enlightenment, even as she bore countless abuses from her paramour.

Together, the two set off a chain of events no one could have ever seen coming. Kahler did a fantastic job both painting the scene and using their own words to bring them to life all over again. It was fascinating to feel the devotion radiating off Dore even as her beloved doctor abused her over and over. Through her writings, you can see how a person in a situation can delude themselves into thinking things truly will be alright, if they can only bear it a little longer. Also through both of their documents, as well as newspaper clippings from interviews, you can see the burgeoning narcissism of Friedrich. Kahler was wise to let Ritter’s own words and deeds speak for himself, as anything else would make him almost too villainous to believe. I was especially drawn to their dynamic as time went on. You could feel the strain, yet Dore continued in her diaries to fudge the truth, while instead expressing her innermost thoughts via stories she would send away.

The Whittemers were simpler, a German family drawn to the island for the peace it offered in return for their hard work. They are truly the one ones on the island who stayed true to their initial mission. It was especially interesting to see how Margret and Dore could have such wildly different tellings of the same events. I must say, I found Margret to be a much more reliable narrator than Dore.

And finally, we come to the throuple—The Baroness with her two young lovers, Rudolph Lorenz and Robert Philippson. Such a woman seems fantastical, almost imaginary in scope, except for the clear evidence that she did indeed exist. I would love to see a psychological analysis done on her because its insane how she was able to trap so many men into her web, as well as governments, while building such hostility amongst her neighbors. While Friedrich and Dore started Fiedo, and by extension, the whole Galapagos Affair, nothing truly took off until The Baroness entered the picture. And oomph. I mean, she even had a film crew out there at one point. Just insanity!

I appreciate how Kahler took the time to lay the groundwork before diving straight into the meat and potatoes of what happened. I did find the first bit rather dull, but it was necessary to give the full effect. I went through the full range of emotions reading this book—shock, disgust, happiness, rage, sadness, anxiety, and horror. While no one will ever truly know the full extent of what happened on Floreana, Eden Undone should be noted as a masterpiece in researched, nuanced storytelling that truly makes the facts come alive in your hands. Still, after reading, and through no fault of the author, I’m left with more questions than answers.

Spoilers Below

*****************

If you ask me (and you read down here, so I’m taking it as you asked me), I believe Friedrich killed The Baroness and Robert Phillipson. His ego was so fragile, between her choosing who could and couldn’t dock on the island, sending smear campaigns (some I’m sure, he deserved) into the news, and her constant threats to his way of life, I just don’t think he could take it. His fantasies about killing her are documented, and I truly think he did it, and along with Dore, concocted the woman’s scream story to cover it up.

I also believe Dore killed Friedrich and after his near-constant abuse, I don’t blame her! That said, while not as bad as him, she wasn’t a fresh daisy either. I believe she actively helped cover up the murders he committed, lied in her diaries about key facts, and was unnecessarily rude to the Whittmers. Her supposed devotion to Friedrich made her a fanatic, something even today we know all too well can be just as dangerous, if not more so than the cult leader. Ultimately, I think Floreana and her mysteries doled out some wild justice, even if we’ll never know the truth of it.

Rating: 4.5 Stars

Savannah R. Fischer is the permanently exhausted pigeon in charge of two well-loved chaos gremlins. When not with her family, she can usually be found in her cave, wrapped in an oversized blanket and dreaming of spinach puffs. She wants to show her gremlins that they can do hard things, even when it’s scary, like pulling the wrong lever and ending up in a pit of alligators. No llamas were harmed in the making of her works of horror.

PLEASE NOTE: The views and opinions of the staff of Memento Mori Ink do not necessarily represent those of Memento Mori Ink or Crystal Lake Publishing. Thank you for understanding.


Discover more from MEMENTO MORI INK MAGAZINE

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.